This episode’s featured track, “Where Owls Know My Name” by Rivers of Nihil, was originally mixed by the powerhouse duo of Carson Slovak and Grant McFarland. Working out of Atrium Audio in Pennsylvania, they have become go-to producers in modern metalcore and progressive metal. Their extensive discography includes multiple acclaimed albums for bands like August Burns Red, Polaris, Erra, and Of Mice & Men, with their work on Rivers of Nihil’s material being a notable highlight of their career.
In This Episode
Hosts Eyal Levi and John Maciel sit down to critique URM student mixes of the incredibly dynamic Rivers of Nihil track, “Where Owls Know My Name.” This episode is a goldmine of practical advice, as they break down the common pitfalls mixers face when tackling a song with such drastic shifts in feel. They dig into recurring issues like thin, “wiry” snare tones, uncontrolled low-end, and drums that sound out of place between soft and heavy sections. A key theme is the absolute necessity of having a clear artistic vision; a mix can be technically okay but fail if it doesn’t serve the song’s emotional journey. Eyal and John also discuss the dangers of an overcooked mastering chain, weird phasing from over-compression, and the importance of balancing sections so the heavy parts actually hit with more impact than the quiet ones. It’s a super helpful look at what separates a demo-sounding mix from a professional one.
Products Mentioned
- Sonarworks
- Joey Sturgis Tones – Tone Forge Menace
- Joey Sturgis Tones – Gain Reduction
- Drum Forge
- Empire Ears In-Ear Monitors
Timestamps
- [04:05] Why this song is a “playground mix” for engineers
- [07:27] Critiquing a mix with a “wiry” snare and weird high-end on the drums
- [09:12] Why boosting 7k on a snare can make it sound thinner
- [14:00] Breaking down a mix that’s too loud, too bright, and has a weird “squeaky” sound
- [16:18] How a bad listening environment can lead to overly loud toms
- [17:10] The importance of overheads and room mics for a cohesive tom sound
- [19:38] Why you can’t approach a soft intro like it’s a heavy part
- [20:35] The “fog of guitar” analogy for when rhythm guitars are too loud
- [22:15] How a bad mastering chain can ruin an otherwise decent mix
- [23:35] The problem with “top-down mixing” for beginners
- [28:50] What happens when the soft buildup is bigger than the actual band
- [30:27] Identifying the sound of a mix distorting from out-of-control bass
- [31:25] The curse of “water toms” that have no impact
- [34:00] Praising a mix that has great artistic vision, even if the technical skills aren’t there yet
- [36:30] How a mix can sound like a “producer demo” with good ideas but poor execution
- [37:30] The problem with distracting snare reverbs on fills
- [41:03] A mix where the heavy parts sound smaller than the soft parts
- [42:43] Diagnosing an “illusion of low end” where the bass is loud but not tight
- [44:27] Why you can’t just focus on the heavy parts and ignore the rest of the song